Before we get started: I'm not saying there's anything wrong with downtown restaurants. On the contrary, that's what I'm mostly going to patronize.
But, maybe there are folks who want to explore a bit farther out. This is why I posted the thread. People who have suggestions about places an Uber/Lyft or car trip away should please feel free to add your recommendations here.
-----
I'll start: Lou Malnati's pizza. They're a Chicago deep dish joint that finally expanded out to Indiana. They're my favorites out of all the big names from that city (Gino's, Uno's/Due's, Giordano's. etc.). Most of the Indy locations are delivery/carry out only, but the Broad Ripple location has dine-in tables. They're 8.2 miles from the ICC according to Google, so IMO it's definitely a car ride away.